Federal practice only

Request a consultation

Law changes

Who May Now Attend the Commission's Nonpublic Meetings

On November 13, 2026, the U.S. Sentencing Commission voted to change one of its own procedural rules. Under amended Rule 3.1, the Chair must invite one representative of the federal judges' Committee on Criminal Law and one representative of the federal defenders to the Commission's nonpublic meetings. The vote does not change any guideline or any sentence. It changes who is in the room while guideline amendments are being worked out. The Commission announced it in a news release and posted the adopted amendment the same day.

What changed

The Commission writes the federal sentencing guidelines. Its Rules of Practice and Procedure govern how it meets, votes, and takes public comment. 28 U.S.C. § 995(a)(1) lets the Commission adopt rules like these by a majority vote.

Until now, Rule 3.1 had two short paragraphs. The version adopted in 2016 said nothing in that rule about outside attendees. A separate rule, Rule 3.3, already let the Chair call a nonpublic meeting to hear from "interested parties within the judicial branch," and it named the Criminal Law Committee and the Federal Public and Community Defenders as examples.

The text made available at the November 13 meeting adds a new paragraph (c) to Rule 3.1. It says that two people "shall be invited by the Chair to attend all nonpublic Commission meetings at which Commission staff is present":

  • one representative designated by the Committee on Criminal Law of the Judicial Conference of the United States.
  • one representative designated by the Sentencing Guidelines Committee for the Federal Public and Community Defenders. These are the defender offices set up under 18 U.S.C. § 3006A(g) to represent people in federal criminal cases who cannot pay for a lawyer.

The rule says they attend so they may provide "any observations, comments or questions pertinent to the work of the Commission." The two representatives also receive, "at the time of distribution, the same meeting materials distributed to commissioners." Each may bring one staff member from their organization.

Why the Commission says it did this

The new paragraph points to 28 U.S.C. § 994(o). That statute tells the Commission to review and revise the guidelines from time to time. It adds that the Commission "shall consult with authorities on, and individual and institutional representatives of, various aspects of the Federal criminal justice system." It lists the Judicial Conference and "a representative of the Federal Public Defenders" among those who send the Commission their comments.

In the news release, Chair Carlton W. Reeves said: "Congress tasked us with working constantly and closely with these key judicial branch stakeholders."

What stays closed to the two representatives

The rule has limits. The Chair "shall exclude designated representatives from portions of meetings, and withhold from them meeting materials," on two kinds of subjects:

  1. Confidential or sensitive matters involving pending litigation involving the Commission, ethics rules and standards, budgetary allocations or appropriations, personnel and staffing matters, and procurement and contract actions.
  2. "[A] rare and unusual matter the Chair has determined requires the utmost confidentiality."

The amendment's synopsis also separates these representatives from ex officio members. An ex officio member sits on the Commission because of another office. Under 28 U.S.C. § 991(a), the Attorney General or a designee is an ex officio, nonvoting member. The synopsis says the two new representatives "are not empowered to participate alongside commissioners at public meetings or hearings."

How this differs from the September proposal

The Commission published a larger set of proposed rule changes on September 3, 2026, at 91 Fed. Reg. 56724, and took comment through October 26, 2026. That notice had eight parts. Part C covered these two representatives. It would also have changed Rule 3.4 to let them take part in public hearings "alongside commissioners" and question witnesses.

The amendment posted on November 13 shows a change to Rule 3.1 only. The other parts of the September notice covered different subjects, including the number of votes needed to make a guideline amendment retroactive (apply to people already sentenced), ex parte communications (contacts with commissioners outside the public comment process), and public release of meeting materials. The news release says the Commission will keep "evaluating the additional Rules revisions it proposed earlier this year."

What is not final yet

The posted document is labeled "preliminary." The Commission calls it an "unofficial, 'reader-friendly' form." It also says that "authority to make technical and conforming changes may be exercised and motions to reconsider may be made," and that the official text of the revised rules will be posted on its website. The documents posted on November 13 do not give the vote count or the date of the first meeting the new representatives will attend.

Who it affects

  • People who will be sentenced in federal court, and people already serving a sentence. Nothing changes today. No guideline range moved, and no one can ask a court for a lower sentence based on this vote.
  • Anyone following guideline amendments. A judge-designated representative and a defender-designated representative will see the same materials commissioners see and can raise questions in those meetings.
  • People waiting on a retroactivity decision. The proposed voting rule for retroactivity was not part of the November 13 amendment. Check the Commission's amendments page for the official text when it is posted.

Source: USSC Rules of Practice and Procedure, Rule 3.1 (amendment adopted November 13, 2026)