Federal practice only

Request a consultation

Court decisions

Why a Tennessee Robbery Conviction Still Triggers the ACCA

On November 19, 2026, the Sixth Circuit decided United States v. Bobo, No. 26-5145. The court held that a Tennessee robbery conviction still counts as a "violent felony" under the Armed Career Criminal Act (ACCA), even after a 2025 Tennessee Supreme Court decision the defense relied on. The court affirmed a sentence of 194 months in prison for possessing a firearm after a felony conviction. Read the decision (PDF).

The opinion is published. Judge Griffin wrote it for a three-judge panel.

What happened

According to the opinion, Tennessee police were investigating Justin Bobo for aggravated assault when they found a firearm under the driver's seat of his vehicle. A federal grand jury charged him with possessing a firearm as a convicted felon, with an enhanced penalty under the ACCA.

Bobo pleaded guilty. He admitted three prior Tennessee felony convictions: robbery in 2010, aggravated robbery in 2012 and aggravated assault in 2022. He kept the right to argue that the 2010 robbery did not count under the ACCA.

The presentence report (the probation office's report to the judge before sentencing) counted all three convictions. With the ACCA applied, it calculated a guidelines range of 188 to 235 months. Bobo objected. The district judge overruled the objection and imposed 194 months. Bobo appealed on that one issue.

What the ACCA does

The ACCA is a federal sentencing law, 18 U.S.C. § 924(e). It applies to a person who violates the federal ban on gun possession in 18 U.S.C. § 922(g) and has three earlier convictions for a "violent felony" or a "serious drug offense," committed on different occasions.

The difference is large. Without the ACCA, the penalty for that gun offense is "not more than 15 years" in prison under § 924(a)(8). With it, the sentence must be "not less than fifteen years" under § 924(e)(1). A required floor like that is called a mandatory minimum. Our guides to the Armed Career Criminal Act and to mandatory minimum sentences explain how it works.

One way a prior conviction counts as a violent felony is through what lawyers call the elements clause. Under § 924(e)(2)(B)(i), the crime must be punishable by more than one year and have "as an element the use, attempted use, or threatened use of physical force against the person of another." An element is something the prosecution has to prove to get a conviction.

How a court decides whether a prior counts

To decide whether a crime is a violent felony, the Sixth Circuit said, "we look to its statutory definition." The question is what the law required for a conviction.

Tennessee's robbery statute, as quoted in the opinion, covers theft from a person "by violence" or by "putting the person in fear." The Sixth Circuit had already addressed that statute in United States v. Mitchell, 743 F.3d 1054 (6th Cir. 2014). Mitchell relied on Tennessee Supreme Court decisions that defined the fear element as "a fear of bodily injury and of present personal peril" from physical force "offered or impending." On that reading, Mitchell held that Tennessee robbery "directly corresponds" to the ACCA's elements clause. The Bobo opinion notes that the court has "repeatedly reaffirmed" that holding.

The argument from the new state decision

Bobo argued that a 2025 Tennessee Supreme Court decision, State v. Curry, 705 S.W.3d 176 (Tenn. 2025), changed the picture. In his view, Curry meant a person could now be convicted of robbery by fear "without attempting or threatening violence." If so, the offense would no longer fit the elements clause.

The Sixth Circuit disagreed. It read Curry as a decision about a different Tennessee law, the state's unlawful firearm possession statute. That statute has its own "crime of violence" element. According to the opinion, Curry decided how the state must prove that element when the earlier felony is a robbery.

In the Sixth Circuit's words, "Curry did not reinterpret the fear element of robbery." The earlier Tennessee definition of that element "still controls." Because Mitchell rested on that definition, "Mitchell still controls as well." The 2010 robbery conviction therefore counted, and the court affirmed.

Who it affects

  • People charged under § 922(g) in the Sixth Circuit (Kentucky, Michigan, Ohio and Tennessee) who have a prior Tennessee robbery conviction. Under Bobo, that conviction still counts toward the three the ACCA requires.
  • People raising a new state court decision against an old federal precedent. The court asked a narrow question: did the state decision change what the state must prove for the prior offense itself? Here the answer was no, because the state decision interpreted a different statute.
  • Anyone reviewing prior convictions before a plea or sentencing. Bobo decided one issue about one Tennessee offense. It did not address the other two convictions, which Bobo did not challenge on appeal, or the rule that the prior offenses be committed on different occasions. Each prior conviction has to be checked against the federal definition on its own.

Bobo kept this issue alive by reserving it when he pleaded guilty and by objecting at sentencing. The opinion reviewed the question "de novo," meaning the court of appeals decided it fresh, without deferring to the district judge.

Source: United States v. Bobo, U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit, No. 26-5145